![]() |
Le Regroupement inter-organismes pour une politique familiale au Québec |
|
Pensons famille |
Volume 9, numéro 51, septembre 1997 |
|
Mrs. Karine Bates
Ph.D in anthropology
McGill University, Montreal, Canada
The impact of AIDS on
families
or the conditions of life of the infected persons and their
families
Content
Foreword
Introduction
1. Presentation
1.1 Methodology
1.2 Definition of family
2. Particulars
regarding HIV-AIDS
2.1 Types of transmission
2.2 Portrait of the infected population
3. Impact of AIDS on families
3.1 In general
3.2 According to the type of transmission
3.3 The time of disclosure
3.4 The cultural community
3.5 According to the region
3.6 Aboriginal communities
3.7 The importance of the familial dynamic before disclosure of
the illness
3.8 The workplace
4. Acceptance / Integretion within the
family
4.1 Needs of the family and friends
a. Information
b. Medical resources
c. Legal problems
d. Need for a break
e. Support
4.2 Resources available for families and friends
4.3 The period during which the person is HIV positive
4.4 The period of AIDS
4.5 Preparation for death and post-death
4.6 To which extent are the resources available?
4.7 Are the resources used?
4.8 Who uses the resources?
4.9 In the regions
4.10 Determinants of integration
5. Recent changes in the health care
system
5. 1 Treatments
6. Provincial & Federal policies
on AIDS
Conclusion
Bibliography
The impact of AIDS on families or the conditions of
life of infected persons and their families
Foreword
This paper is the result of a study conducted for the
Regroupement inter-organismes pour une politique familiale au
Québec (RIOPFO). This organization is a coalition of different
groups that are working in the interest of families. The RIOPFQ
is the leading representative of the family movement vis-à-vis
the Government of Quebec. The purpose of this study is to inform
the members of the RIOPFQ and the final report may also be used
in future consultations with the Government and other public
organizations.
The research was mainly based in Montreal. Approximately one
million people live in Montreal. It is the metropolis of the
Province of Quebec, which has a population of 7 million. Quebec
is the only French province in Canada and this paper is an
English translation of the original french version 1.
Introduction
This paper is the final report of the study on the
impact of AIDS on families. This study had two main objectives.
The first is to investigate the dynamic of the personal
relationships between HIV positive people and their families. The
second is to explore the types of resources available for
families in Quebec. These resources can respond to different
needs of families whether economic, technical or emotional.
This study springboards from the desire of the RIOPFQ to know
more about how AIDS affects the relationship between the HIV
positive person and his or her family. In contrast to other
diseases (like cancer), we do not hear about resources for
families. This lack of information is what inspired the present
study.
This research project provided an opportunity to establish
central database regarding the problems associated with AIDS. As
will be seen, the problems can only be analysed accurately if the
variable situations of the families are taken into account This
variability exists as a result of the factors that influence the
situation of HIV positive people and their families. The main
factors are: geographic region, gender, age, type of
transmission, sexual orientation, ethnic community and
relationships between the HIV positive person with his or her
family before the disease.
Despite all these variables, people infected with AIDS share some
common traits. First, AIDS either strengthens familial ties or
destroys them. Second, AIDS awakens the taboos related to
homosexuality. In addition, it also raises the biases concerning
prostitution and drugs. In other words, studying AIDS also means
studying the taboos related to homosexuality, prostitution and
drugs. It also leads to the study of another delicate area:
familial problems.
In order to give a global picture of the situation, this report
contains six general themes:
1. Presentation of the research problem
2. Particulars regarding HIV-AIDS
3. Impact of AIDS on families
4. Acceptance / Integration within the family
5. Recent changes in the health care system
6. Provincial & Federal policies related to AIDS
1. Presentation
1.1 Methodology
Three research methods were concurrently used in order to collect
data for this paper. First, in order to contextualize the
research, an extensive number of documents were consulted. Even
if a lot of information about AIDS is available through
government agencies and libraries, few are dedicated to the
experiences of families and friends of HIV positive persons.
Second, this lack of information was compensated by the data
collected via interviews. Thirty interviews were conducted over
an eight-week period. The respondents were from community
organizations, hospitals, CLSCs
2 and half-way houses. Despite the problem of
confidentiality 3,
I was able to talk with some infected people, their families and
their friends.
Finally, in order to know what is going on outside Montreal, I
contacted the key people who are in charge of organizations which
assist HIV positive people in all regions of Quebec.
1.2 Definition of Family
In the context of AIDS, the concept of family has different
meanings. This is why when reading the word family one has to
keep in mind that it generally includes a social network. When
necessary, I will distinguish between close kin (mother, father,
brother, sister), extended family (uncles, aunts, cousins),
spouses, common-law partners and social networks (may include
some family members and friends). In many cases, the only person
aware of the disease is the social worker. In this context, they
may also be considered as being the only "family" of
the infected person. The main reason why distinctions are
necessary is because in the homosexual community (which is the
principal group infected by AIDS), links with the natural family
are often broken. Many homosexuals, however, consider that they
have a family, but it includes people who are not blood
relatives.
2.
Particulars regarding HIV-AIDS
2.1 Types of transmission
The type of transmission has a direct impact on how the
family will react to the HIV positive person. For example, if
someone contracted the virus through a blood transfusion, the
probabilities that he or she will be rejected by his or her
family are lower than if he or she contracted the disease through
homosexual relations. Indeed, the three main types of
transmissions are: sexual intercourse (homosexuals, bisexual
heterosexual), blood transmission (mainly through the sharing of
contaminated needles and syringes), transmission from mother to
child (during pregnancy, delivery, and more rarely during
breast-feeding).
2.2 Portrait of the infected population
While statistics in Quebec are quite accurate it remains
difficult to get the exact picture of the situation of AIDS in
the Province, because all infected people are not yet identified.
Without a diagnosis, it is not possible to record the exact
number of people infected. On the other hand, when someone is
diagnosed, the case is reported to the AIDS Surveillance Program
of Quebec.
In Quebec, 67 out of 100, 000 persons are infected. This is the
second highest rate in Canada after Ontario. As of June 1998, a
total of 5308 cases were declared to the AIDS Surveillance
Program. Sixty-four percent of these reported cases have resulted
in death. Nearly 89% of the infected people are male and 98% of
all AIDS people are over 15 years. At an international level,
Africa comes first with a rate of 900 out of 100, 000.
A growing number of reported cases come from the heterosexual
community. This implies that an increasing number of women are
now HIV positive. The sharing of needles or syringes for
injecting drugs like cocaine, heroin or steroids can transmit
infected blood from one person to another. It is now, in addition
to sexual intercourse with an infected person, the main reason
why heterosexuals are infected with the HIV virus. Adequate
screening of blood began in November 1985. Since then,
heterosexuals (and homosexuals) are no longer infected by HIV
virus through blood tranfusions.
Children are a new demographic group infected by contaminated
blood. With a growing number of women infected with AIDS, new
born babies are more frequently diagnosed with the disease. There
is a 15-25% chance that an infected mother will transmit HIV to
her baby during pregnancy, at birth or during breast feeding.
3. Impact of
AIDS on families
3.1 In general
Taboos concerning AIDS imply that families and society in general
make clear distinctions between the different types of
transmission of AIDS. This reasoning implies that HIV positive
people are not simply considered as sick people with a disease.
They are considered as sick people surrounded by taboos. At the
same time they become victims of prejudice and disease.
Families have two main types of reactions. First, there is shame.
Families are afraid of being rejected by their social network
because of gossip concerning the infected person's sexual
orientation or concerning a possible drug addiction of the HIV
positive person. Shame inevitably leads to the creation of a
distance between the families and the infected person. Exclusion
may also be a consequence of shame.
The second type of reaction is a sense of powerlessness, which
entails sadness. Consequently, AIDS can bring some family members
and friends closer to the sick person. On the other hand, the
fear of losing a loved one may create tension and some members of
the family may prefer not to be with the infected person because
he or she may die soon.
AIDS provokes another type of complex reactions. Even in cases
where the HIV positive person is welcome, another problem exists:
the fear of contamination. Despite the publicity campaigns on the
ways in which AIDS can be transmitted, a lot of people remain
unaware of the facts. Consequently, they think that there are
risks in touching an infected person or using the same bathroom
or the same dishes. In order to make sure that warm relations can
be established, it is very important that people receive accurate
information about how AIDS can be transmitted. Discrimination is
less important among the homosexual community because they are
very well informed.
In general, the extended family is not the most supportive.
Mother, father, sisters and brothers are generally more accepting
and supportive. Parents that are older, however, have more
difficulty accepting the situation. It is even more difficult if
the virus was contracted as a result of homosexual relationships
because many elderly people are not as accepting of homosexuality
and drug addiction.
Among close members of the family the mother is the one who
generally helps the most. She keeps the disease a secret and
takes care of her children. If the mother is unable to do this,
often another female figure, like a sister or a girl friend will
take on that role. In other words, it is generally a woman who
first becomes aware of the disease of the infected person. If an
infected person is a male homosexual, his partner will be
supportive and understanding, unless there is a separation.
The variety of potential reactions implies that HIV positive
people have to carefully choose with whom they will discuss their
situation carefully. Bad reactions from people you love can turn
out to be a burden. The problem is that it is not possible to
know in advance what kind of reaction to expect.
3.2 According to the type of transmission
Most of the time, shame comes from taboos surrounding
homosexuality. Even if there are fewer prejudices toward
homosexuality since the '70s, homosexuals are still victims of
all kinds of social stigmatization. For many years homosexuals
formed the group in society at the highest risk, which is why the
population often associates AIDS with homosexuality. This
situation signifies that if homosexuality is not well accepted by
a family, AIDS will certainly not improve the relations between
the infected and the family. For some people, AIDS is a just
punishment for homosexuality. In other words, people tend to say
that if a homosexual contracted AIDS he deserved it. For all
these reasons, a homosexual with AIDS has little chance of being
accepted by members of a family who does not accept
homosexuality. On the other hand, in the homosexual community,
common-law partners and friends are more able to accept AIDS.
In cases of infection by blood transfusions or by utilization of
other blood products contaminated with the virus, there is a lot
of anger. Either the infected people or their relatives and
friends will be angry toward the medical system that permitted
these fatal transfusions. Even if the disease was transmitted by
infected blood, many cases show that some members of the family
still remained suspiscious about the cause of AIDS. They will
continue to suspect that the person had homosexual relations or
took narcotics.
These ambiguities do not exist in cases of hemophilia It is
easier to accept AIDS for the family in the sense that it is a «
real » accident. But again, nothing is simple with AIDS. The
taboos about AIDS render it difficult to disclose the disease.
Firstly, the infected people, as well as their family and friends
are in general very angry with the system. Secondly, they do no
easily talk about AIDS with their family and friends because of
the fear that they will think it is a case of bisexuality or drug
use. So, the isolation is very painful for the sick person and
the people who take care of them. The people who know about the
disease will keep it secret in order to respect the private life
of the infected person. The importance of confidentiality implies
that the people close to the infected person are also isolated.
Consequently, it is more difficult to find technical 4 or moral support.
For a mother who transmits AIDS to her child, the pain is very
intense. The feeling of guilt is also very present. At the same
time, she tends to question her past or the type of relations she
had.
If a married man dies of AIDS because he was bisexual, the
reactions of the family are quite different. The differences lie
in the fact that at the time of the death, the wife and the
children may learn that he had sexual relations with other men
while he was married. This is obviously a huge shock; these cases
raise serious questions regarding infidelity and homosexuality,
as everybody thought that the husband / father was loyal and
heterosexual.
3.3 The time of disclosure
If the HIV positive person does not disclose his or her disease
to his or her family until the AIDS symptoms start, it is
sometimes more difficult for the family to accept it. Because
death is close, the pain is more acute. The family members also
wonder why they did not learn about it before. Why did the
infected person say nothing? What did they fail to do to create a
feeling of confidence? Here it is important to note that the
infected person will often choose not to talk about their disease
to the people they love in order not to worry them. They may also
make this decision because they want to continue a « normal »
life.
It is easier for families to cope with the new reality if they
know about the situation at the very beginning, mainly because
they have the chance to spend quality time with the infected
person. The chance to see the person in good health for some
years is an opportunity to ease into the sorrowful situation. But
one has to be careful not to associate good health with absence
of disease.
The most difficult experience for the family is to learn at the
same time that the person is homosexual and has contracted AIDS.
This situation is also difficult for the HIV positive person,
because if his or her family did not know about his or her sexual
orientation it is generally because he or she did not have close
relationships with them.
3.4 The cultural community
It is not possible to describe the situation in every cultural
community, as each community could be the subject of a separate
study. What is common to all of these communities is the fact
that people perceive it essential for women to have children. The
capacity to give birth is part of a woman's role and if she is
not able to fulfil this role it is considered to be a
malediction. So, if a woman is HIV positive, there will often be
a denial of the disease and she will continue to have children
despite the high risk of contamination.
This denial of the disease implies that the woman will not talk
too much about her disease, dangerously increasing the
possibility of contaminating the people with whom she lives. On
the other hand, medical intervention is problematic in houses
where there are taboos towards AIDS. Also, people in these
communities know each other. Confidentiality being very
important, they may be afraid to use local resources which have
been adapted to their needs and culture because they fear being
recognized.
Finally, certain religious beliefs will increase the feeling of
guilt. In groups where death is seen as an eternal journey in
paradise or in hell, AIDS, homosexuality or narcotic addiction
are perceived as a sin.
3.5 According to the region 5
Outside Montreal, the population is smaller; people know each
other and it may be an obstacle for family and friends to ask for
help if they want to preserve confidentiality. Fortunately, HIV
positive people are generally well accepted by their family in
these regions. But more often, the extended family will not know
about the disease; only close family members will be aware of it.
The main reason for this can be found again in the social taboos
linked with AIDS. These taboos are even more present in regions
outside Montreal. Fewer homosexuals live in regions outside
Montreal. Many of them will move to Montreal because it is easier
for them to be accepted and to be anonymous in a metropolis 6. The
prejudices surrounding AIDS are also more present in regions
outside Montreal because there is less information about AIDS.
This is a problem, as more and more homosexuals go back to their
home towns to be cured from AIDS or to die.
Everywhere in Quebec, the number of cases where infection
occurred by drug injection has increased. Indeed, in Montreal as
well as in the regions outside Montreal, it is no longer possible
to associate AIDS solely with homosexuality. Bisexuality also
increases the risk of contracting AIDS. But people in the regions
also must cope with the fact that heterosexuals may also have
AIDS. The lack of information is an obstacle to raising this
awareness.
3.6 Aboriginal communities
These communities are also affected the increasing number of AIDS
cases. Certain characteristics of their way of life create
factors of risk such as poverty, monoparental families changes in
the traditional structures of the family, alcohol and drug
problems. Because of the difficulties experienced by many members
of the aboriginal communities, their access to health care or
other resources are ridden with complications. These factors are
to be added to the fact that aboriginal people do not have the
same access to the health system, because access depends on
whether they live on the reserve and on whether they have indian
status.
3.7 The importance of the family dynamic before diclosure
of the illness
If the links between family members and friends are good before
the disclosure of the disease, the relations will be more
harmonious thereafter. If the relationships were not good, the
disease will not change things!
3.8 The workplace
Statistics do not show any cases of AIDS contracted at a
workplace. This can be explained in two ways. Firstly, in order
to be considered as a case of « professional » AIDS, the risk
factor must be in the work. Secondly, people are afraid to talk
about it in their workplace because most of the time their
colleagues are afraid of this disease. Moreover, the breach of
confidentiality often has a dramatic impact: many infected people
have lost their jobs after confiding in a colleague. We also find
some cases where the infected person was rejected. So close
colleagues may actually become the executioners.
Sex workers 7
are generally considered to be at high risk. But it is important
not to generalize. There are three types of sex workers: street
prostitutes, dancers and escorts (men and women). Activist
organizations pretend that more prostitutes are now using condoms
because they are aware of the risks associated with their work.
Street prostitutes, however, find it more difficult to always use
condoms. Since the police are trying to « clean » the street,
they do not have time to negociate the use of condoms. The
attitude of the police is motivated by the laws against
solicitation. As a consequence, prostitutes have had to move to
different areas. This is why the red light district 8 is smaller than before.
Also, with increasing poverty, more and more women are forced to
engage in prostitution at the end of the month, when their
welfare living allowance is all spent. They will receive clients
at home, thereby creating a space of vulnerability. Because these
women work alone, they are less protected. The situation on the
street used to be different: four or five women would solicit
together, they protected each other and they knew with whom each
was leaving. For the prostitutes who are still working on the
street, the job is much more difficult. Some organizations
distribute condoms and syringes, only to see some policemen take
them away. Young prostitutes, both boys and girls are more
vulnerable. At this age, contrary to the older prostitutes, they
often work for a pimp, which implies that they have more
obligations and that they work under more pressures.
What is interesting, is that contrary to common belief, it is not
through work that sex workers contract AIDS: it is through drugs
injections. Not all prostitutes use drugs however. The
organizations that work with sex workers are adamant that sex
work is not the main source of risk: drugs are the main problem
regarding the transmission of AIDS and the majority of
prostitutes and other sex workers do not take drugs.
For many sex workers, family ties have been broken or, in the
alternative, family members are not always aware of their job. If
the disclosure of AIDS and prostitution is made at the same time,
it may be a huge shock for the family. Again, friends may be a
better source of help. In many cases, however, street-friends
will not be very supportive when someone wants to go through
detoxication.
4. Acceptance / Integration
within the family
Generally, an HIV positive person will not be kept at
the hospital if the person is able to return to his or her home
and pursue a « normal » life. Even if some medicines may have
undesirable effects, the infected person, the doctors and the
social workers feel that it is better for him or her to remain at
home. It is even more important in the case of children. Family
provides a sane environment for the terminally ill.
Overall, more and more family take care of infected people
despite of the taboos surrounding AIDS and homosexuality. So,
even if the situation is not free from tension, it is easier for
families to accept AIDS.
4.1 Needs of the family and friends
HIV positive people and their families may have different needs
in certain respects but in others, they may be similar.
a. Information
At the outset, family and friends need more information
about AIDS. Afterwards, when the virus becomes active, the need
for medical information increases. Ideally, this information
should be personalized. It is, however, very difficult to find
this type of service because in order to know exactly what is
going on, one has to talk directly to the doctor, which requires
the consent of the infected person. Such an agreement is not
always present. In addition, people are not necessarily aware of
the fact that you can accompany someone to the doctor's if they
so desire.
b. Medical resources
In order to efficiently help the infected person when he
or she is sick, it is very important to know what medical
resources are available.
c. Legal problems
People helping the infected person need to know the
rights of the HIV positive person. In the latter stages of the
illness, families also need to know the procedures to obtain a
power of attorney if necessary.
d. Need for a break
During the illness, whoever helps the sick person
requires some rest and will appreciate if someone can give them a
break. It is necessary for them to talk to someone who can advise
them concerning how to take care of themselves. Other practical
services are also necessary: help with cleaning, specialized
medical needs and transportation of the HIV positive person to
medical appointments or other meetings.
e. Support
It is clear that at a psychological level it is very
difficult to take care of someone who is very sick and who may
die. Consequently, family and friends often need some
psychological support through the different stages of the illness
and after the death of the person. It is very important for them
to know that they are not alone: others also have experienced the
loss of someone because of AIDS.
4.2 Resources available for families and friends
There are three main places where family and friends can
find support: in the health care network (hospitals and CLSCs),
in community organizations and in half-way houses. The common
characteristic of these resources is that they are indirect. This
can be explained by two phenomena. First, the majority of the
resources for families are only available if the infected person
agrees to it. Second, few resources have as a main objective to
help family and friends.
When the diagnosis is pronounced, social workers,
psychotherapists and other community workers are always open to
the demands of support from the infected person and family
members. For example, they may organize a family meeting to
provide information about the illness. At the same time, it is an
opportunity to answer all types of questions and to give support
to the family. Short-term psychological support is also available
for family members and friends.
In the hospitals, especially in the AIDS units, doctors are aware
of the importance of the social network of an infected person.
Since the recent budget cuts in the health care system, doctors
inherited a larger responsibility because they have a shorter
period of time in which to treat a person. Meetings between
family helpers and the doctors are possible. Some doctors,
however, are more pro-active than others.
Social workers in hospitals and CLSCs play a very important role.
They organize the return home of the infected person and they
take into account the dynamic of the social network of the sick
person. They must make sure that this person will get good
homecare services. Those who take care of the infected person
stay in touch with social workers. Obviously, some social workers
are more aware of the problems involved with AIDS patients than
others. It is easier for the family if the services are provided
by a specialized group in hospitals and in CLSCs. Unfortunately,
it is not available in every region. When there are no
specialized services for AIDS, help for the HIV positive person
is provided through home care services. When the patient is less
sick, a nurse will make home visits to gave injections or to
verify medications.
Many social organizations provide services, but it is still
difficult to fulfill all the needs. Few groups directly help
family and friends. Resources are mainly available during the
day. 24-hour services are non-existant, which implies that many
people who take care of a HIV positive person rapidly becomes
exhausted. The following is a description of the resources
available for them.
Centre Pierre-Hénault
The mandate of this Centre is to support the people who
take care of the HIV positive person in order to facilitate their
role as companion or caregiver. They also help during the period
of mourning. In addition, they have volunteers who accompany the
HIV positive person to appointments, which provides a break for
the family.
The support is individual on a short-term basis as oppose to long
term support like therapy. There is also the possibility of
getting support through groups: groups for the partners and
spouses, groups for the mothers, groups for the caregivers. These
groups meet every week for a period of eight weeks. Each group is
composed of 5 to 10 participants. The goal is to provide an
opportunity to share experiences with others. It is very
important for people to know that they are not alone going
through such an experience. The need to share is the most
important one after the need to have information about the
disease.
Bethanie 's children (Les enfants de Béthanie)
This organization takes care of 20 to 30 families.
Psychological support is offered through individual meetings or
by phone. It is also possible to match a child with a volunteer,
thus providing a break for parents. This person performs regular
activities with the child and accompanies him or her to medical
appointments. Additional services allowing the parents to take a
break are also available. In addition, celebrations, activities
and summer camps are organized throughout the year.
Canadian Hemophilia Society
This society organizes week-end sessions for infected
people and their families where specialists provide psychological
support and information. It is also possible to call this
organization to ask questions, to know more about the resources
available (at a financial level for example) or simply to break
the isolation.
Ste-Justine's Hospital Centre for mother and child
Ste-Justine hospital specializes in providing health
care for children. They have a Centre where a multidisciplinary
team helps mothers and children with a holistic approach. This
team includes doctors, nurses, social workers, psychologist, a
dietetician, a pharmacist, an ergotherapist, a physiotherapist, a
research assistant, a research coordinator and a care
coordinator. The focus of this Centre is really family oriented.
Half-way houses
Access to such houses is easy. Even people on social
welfare 9
are accomodated. People who are in these homes do not want to die
in the hospital and they can not choose to die in their own
homes. For many infected people, these houses represent a new
family. In general, infected people do not have a lot of contact
with their natural family.
For the family, it is possible to find short-term support in
these houses. For example, they have access to psychological
support and to information on AIDS or on the health of the
infected person. This is done out of respect for the wishes of
the infected person, because he or she may want to maintain some
privacy and will not want people visiting only because he or she
are sick. They do not want to be overprotected.
One bedroom is available for members of family who wish to stay
with the infected person during their last moments. Family and
friends are always welcome and they are free to share a meal
whenever they wish.
Other resources
Even if there are few resources available, all community
organizations and social workers are always ready to support
family members. Most of the time, it is the infected person who
will inform his or her family of the resources available. In
order to know all the available resources, the « Resources Guide
», published in 1997, is an extensive compilation of all
resources in Montreal and in the regions. Those resources can be
consulted on an anonymous basis.
Resources for sex workers
It is increasingly difficult to contact sex workers, especially
the prostitutes, because they are more dispersed than before.
Street workers are very active sensitizing prostitutes to the use
of condoms. They also distribute condoms and syringes. Passage
takes care of people from the street who need a break: they can
stay for a period of one year and regain their physical and
psychological health. On the other hand, Stella is a day centre
where people can go for company, to discuss their situation and
to get legal or health advice. These points are important because
prostitutes may have difficulties getting proper treatment: many
doctors and nurses have prejudices against them and may not take
their problems seriously. Some clinics are more open to their
problems and community organizations try to sensitize the medical
community to the reality of prostitutes.
Overall, there are not many organizations specifically taking
care of the prostitutes. Other groups may indirectly take care of
them such as, Passage, Sero Zero and Cactus. Young men involved
in prostitution more frequently use the services of the two last
orgamzations. Most of the time, families of sex workers are
disfunctional. As such, they are not really present in cases of
AIDS and it is probably why, so far, there is no available
resources to take care of the family members.
4.3 The period during which the person is HIV positive
The HIV positive person can continue to work. In the
particular case of persons with hemophilia, they are compensated
by the government. It is also possible for the HIV positive
person to retire at a younger age. During that period, CLSCs and
other resources are not really active. They play a more important
role when symptoms of the illness are apparent.
For HIV positive person, it is very difficult to deal with
emergency situations. The problem is that when someone is sick,
it is not easy to organize things in advance! On the other hand,
some families ask impossible things, such as the services of a
nurse for 24 hours a day.
When the family needs to contribute financially to the purchase
of medical supplies, some problems may arise, because not all
families are able to help. The problems are even more acute when
the HIV positive person had to leave his or her job because of
AIDS. The government is not very helpful in those cases.
The cases of children. Children are generally not informed of
their illness. It is only around the age of 14 that the family
and social workers will prepare him or her for the realities of
his or her health condition. At this age it is imperative to
inform the adolescent because he or she may engage in sexual
relations. Prevention being the best way to avoid AIDS, the
teenager must use condoms. Generally, the news will be broken in
the presence of a social worker.
Placing children in day-care may be difficult, because day-care
personnel are afraid of contamination. If the latter is not the
case, then few people will know about the illness of the child so
as not to provoke panic among the parents of other children.
4.4 The period of AIDS
HIV infected people decide for themselves where they
want to die. But if their choice is to die at home, social
workers and doctors must insure that the social network is strong
enough. The family must be prepared to take care of someone who
will be very sick and who may not die as quickly as they think.
This possibility implies that the situation will be more
demanding than what may be expected.
CLSCs take care of the services at home. Other organizations can
provide support, a break and psychological services. Many of the
people who are taking care of the dying person nevertheless
become exhausted. Also, many of them have the impression that
they are not doing enough even if they do more than their best to
comfort the infected person.
4.5 Preparation for death and post-death
Living with the probability of death is a series of mourning, for
the infected person as well as for family and friends. For the
people close to the dying person, preparation for death is very
important. Because they are taking care of someone who is very
sick, they often forget about their own needs. Consequently, when
the infected person dies, they feel very empty. Others have a
feeling of guilt, mainly parents who may wonder what they did
wrong. Mourning is never easy, but it is worse if someone is
embarrassed to say that their child died of AIDS.
Individual therapy is available through psychologists. Group
support is a good way to share the experience. The people who
were helping the family at home are also a source of support if
they were able to create some links with family members.
4.6 To which extent are resources available?
HIV positive persons are not always well informed about the
resources available if they are not diagnosed in a specialized
clinic or hospital. Despite the fact that AIDS is now well known,
not all doctors take the necessary steps to make sure that the
infected person has a supportive social network. On the other
hand, even if the family is well informed about the resources,
they have to work hard to obtain services. Many phone calls and
meetings are required. Organizing home care services is a lot of
work which is easier if the families work with a specialized
CLSC. But once again it is not easy to know where to obtain all
the resources are. Publicity is mainly done inside the health
network. For example, community services are publicized in
clinics or in CLSCs. So the population in general has limited
knowledge of those resources.
One of the most important problems in their search is the fact
that when the infected person locks for available resources, they
can not always identify themselves. They can't leave a message or
give personal information. For example, if a mother is the only
person who knows about the illness of her child, she will only be
able to make phone calls when her husband is not there. The same
applies to meetings: she will only be able to attend if she can
find a good excuse justifying her absence from home.
4.7 Are resources used?
When families accept the infected person, they do not
often use the available resources. Even though they may also need
less psychological support, they still need information
concerning medicine. The problem of confidentiality, however,
limits the utilization of resources.
4.8 Who uses the resources?
Women are the main users of the resources. As discussed, the
mother is the one who is most present while fathers are less
present: Quebec culture makes it difficult for men to express
their need for help.
Generally women are heterosexual: when they seek help, they do
not want to be with homosexuals, not because of prejudices, but
because their experiences are different. Because the homosexual
community was the first victim of AIDS, the heterosexual AIDS
community is often forgotten by support services. It is hard for
a HIV positive man to find support when he is heterosexual or
bisexual.
4.9 In the regions
We can hardly find more than one organization in each region of
the Province of Quebec. Montreal is really the AIDS center. Some
families meet obstacles because the health care personnel do not
have equal knowledge of AIDS as those in Montreal. Having to
travel long distances complicates the experience. Regions are so
vast that people need to drive many kilometers to reach the
hospital.
The reputation of the family in the region is very important to
preserve because there is no anonymity. In order not to be
identified, few people participate in support groups. This is why
individual help is more popular.
4.10 Determmants of integration
There are no socio-economic factors determining the extent to
which an infected person will be accepted by his or her family.
It is, however, possible to analyse the influence of two
variables: education and economic status.
In more educated groups, the knowledge of AIDS is more extensive.
But education does not guarantee the emotional capacity to accept
such an illness and inevitable death. So, for an infected person,
it is not necessarily easier to deal with illness even if the
family members are educated.
Richer families have less difficulties to cope with the cost of
medicine and private health services.
This represents fewer worries for the family; but it sometimes
means that family will be less
involved and will lack interest in the infected person's
problems. People who are well known (like
doctors or lawyers) will sometimes hide the sick person to
protect their reputation. On an
emotional level the disclosure of this disease is often worse
because, in these groups, people often
think that it will never happen to them.
Economically disadvantaged groups are sometimes more aware of the
resources available, which may compensate for their financial
problems. On the other hand, homosexuality is not very well
accepted, AIDS is often seen simply as one more problem...
These are the only variables which may influence their reaction
to AIDS. Money and education do not dictate the capacity to cope
with illness and death.
5. Recent changes in the
health care system
The budget cuts made to the health care system in order to erase
the provincial deficit had an impact on infected people. First,
overnight stays at the hospital stay are for a shorter period of
time. The families must take on the responsibility of caring for
the infected person sooner. Social workers and community
organizations are getting more demands for support. It is a
heavier task to be accomplished with less money than at the
beginning of the epidemic.
A growing number of people have difficulties paying for their
medicine. The special governmental programs to help HIV positive
people to pay for medicine have been abolished. A person may be
required to pay between $1000 and $1500 per month 10. For people without
private insurance, the cost is enormous. But even if they have
insurance from their workplace, people are afraid to claim
reimbursement for their medicine because this may breach
confidentiality. Many infected people lose their jobs under these
circumstances. Under such conditions, families and friends must
play an important role.
5.1 Treatments
The evolution of medicine for AIDS is growing rapidly. It is a
real source of hope. But this may be misleading: AIDS is still
fetal and no definitive cure has been found. So far, medicine
only prolongs the lives of infected people. Also, not everybody
reacts positively to new medicine. Some are very sick and no
appropriate treatment can be found for them. At a psychological
level the possibility of death is still there. It is hard for
both the infected person and their family.
New treatments have changed the intervention of some community
services because AIDS is not as often a crisis situation. Science
has also changed its perspective on AIDS. Scientists have begun
to consider this illness as a chronic disease (like diabetes).
This new status for AIDS may eventually change the financial
amounts allocated to governmental programs for AIDS.
6. Provincial &
Federal policies on AIDS
In June 1997, the Government of Quebec initiated a five-year
program in a fight against AIDS. The budget of this program is 19
million dollars:
- 7.1 million for the prevention and surveillance of AIDS;
- 5.6 million to take care of the HIV-AIDS people in the health
care system;
- balance for research and health-cure assistance.
This new phase has three main objectives: (1) health promotion
and prevention, (2) power redistribution, (3) reoorganisation of
the services in the context of general budget cuts in the health
care system of the province. The Government also wanted to
develop home care services and other resources in every region of
Quebec. Few concrete measures, however, were announced, so it is
not possible to say whether families of AIDS patients will be
taken into consideration.
This government program began its fourth phase in 1997, the first
one started in 1989. The Federal Government, at times, allocates
money to support Provincial Government programs and initiatives
(even if health is a provincial jurisdiction) that decided to
stop providing money for AIDS. This decision has created
important difficulties for community organizations: they must
find money elsewhere and some may simply have to close.
Conclusion
There is no family-oriented philosophy in the case of
AIDS. Most of the resources are for the infected person. But the
holistic approach of many services help the HIV positive person
and may, directly and indirectly, help family and friends. This
holistic approach may be the best way for facilities to properly
adjust themselves to the budget cuts, the new medicines and the
new group of infected heterosexual people.
AIDS is seen as a real « test » for families. On one hand, this
illness may reinforce the strong links already existing in a
family. But AIDS may also increase the tension in a disfunctional
family which has difficulties accepting homosexuality,
prostitution, and drug addiction. AIDS also invokes fear of
death.
The best way to prevent AIDS is through education. We all must
remember that the family is the best place to talk about safe sex
and that government and other resources can only complement this
very important social unit.
Bibliography
AIDS Committee of Toronto, Living with dying: dying at
home, Canadian Cataloguing in Publication Data, Toronto, 1994.
BOURGEON, M. et RENAUD, G., « Sida: l'animation d'un groupe de
proches et la recherche de signification », Intervention, no.
86, Septembre 1990, pp.23-34.
Centre Pierre-Hénault, Confidences, Bibliothèque nationale du
Québec, 1996.
Collège des médecins de famille du Canada, Nourissons, enfants
et préadolescents, Santé Canada, Mississauga, 1995.
Centre québécois de coordination sur le sida, Les femmes et le
sida; les enjeux, Bibliothèque nationale du Québec, 1991.
Centre québécois de coordination sur le sida, Prostitution et
VIH au Québec: bilan de connaissances, Direction de la santé
publique de Montréal Centre, 1995.
Comité des personnes atteintes du virus d'immunodéficience au
Québec, Ma vie continue, Editions Emmanuèle Garnier, Montréal,
1994.
CSN, Pour mieux faire face à la problématique du sida en milieu
de travail, Montréal, 1997.
FONTAINE, G., « Pistes d'intervention », Le Bulletin de
1'ESPOIR, vol. III (no. 2), Octobre 1993, p. 1.
GOLDE, S., « Les enfants nés de mères ayant le VIH / sida: Les
problèmes psychosociaux des familles canadiennes vivant avec le
VIH ou le sida - un rapport préliminaire », Le travailleur
social, vol. 64 (no. 4) Hiver 1996, pp. 5972.
Centre de coordination sur le sida (MSSSQ), Comment prendre soin
d'une personne vivant avec le sida. Informations à l'intention
des amis, des proches, des membres de la famille et des autres
personnes qui s'occupent d'une personne vivant avec le sida à la
maison, Bibliothèque nationale du Québec, 1995.
LABERGE-FERRON, D., « Le sida: un défi de société »,
Sida-presse, vol. 1 (no. 1), Sept.-Oct.-Nov. 1990, pp. 1-2.
LE CLERC, R., Les maisons où la mort vit, Bibliothèque
nationale du Québec, 1997.
Ministère de la Santé et des Services sociaux, Stratégie
québécoise de lutte contre le sida; Phase 4, Bibliothèque
nationale du Québec, 1997.
OLIVER, C., ROBERT, J. et THOMAS, R. et al., Le SIDA,
Bibliothèque nationale du Québec, 1995.
PATTERSON, B. et ROBICHAUD, P., Vous et votre santé; Un guide à
l'intention des personnes vivant avec le VIH ou le sida, Edité
par RCITS, CATIE et The Toronto People With AIDS Foundation,
1996.
REIDY, M. et TAGGART, M.-E. et al., VIH / sida; une approche
mudidisciplinaire, Gaétan Morin éditeur, Montréal, 1995.
RUFFIOT, A., Psychologie du SIDA, Editions Pierre Mardaga,
Liège, 1989.
SAMSON, J. et al., « Le sida maternel et infantile »,
P.R.I.S.M.E., été 1992, pp.496-508.
Société canadienne d'hémophilie, Deuil, VIH et sida: guide
personnel de réconfort et d'information, Montréal,
Bibliothèque nationale du Canada, 1995.
TAYLOR, S. et al., « Confidentialité et devoir de protection:
Un dilemme éthique concernant les clients vivant avec le VIH /
sida », Le travailleur social, vol. 64 (no. 4). HIVER 1996, PP.9
à 19.
Notes
1. This is an unofficial translation of the french version. Thanks to Judith Mitchell, Nicole Sigouin & Sonia Kesik-Mitchell for reviewing the English version. Their collaboration was very much appreciated This version also provides new information concerning prostitution. In addition, we want to thank the organizations of Stella and Passage for their collaboration.
2.Centre local de santé communautaire (Local Centre for Community Health).
3. Confidentiality is a very important issue because AIDS is linked to many taboos and, as will be seen breach of confidentiality may have dramatic consequences.
4. In order to take care of someone who is very sick you may have to do renovations in your house or appartment: special beds or adapted toilets.
5. The province of Quebec is divided in 10 regions.
6. Even if homosexuals are in all socio-economic spheres of the society, in Montreal (like in the majority of metropolitan areas in America and Europe) there is an area where they can live more "freely". This area is open to everybody, but homosexuals are able to express their own sexual orientation. It is mostly homosexual men that occupy this area, lesbians being more dispersed. There is less of a need for a lesbian area partly because in general we are less suspicious when we see women showing affection to each other Unlike other societies, it is rarer in North America to see two men holding hands or hanging shoulders. Specialized ressources for HIV positive people find their origins in this area. Nowadays, however, it is possible to find help eveywhere.
7. It is not possible to evaluate the number of sex workers in Quebec, mainly because of the illegality of solicitation and the clandestine character of the activity. Estimates indicate that in 1984, 3000 adult prostitutes were working in the Montreal region and 100 in Quebec city region. Numbers are even more striking in the case of minors ( less than 18 years old): around 5000 young people are prostitutes in the Montreal region and between 500-800 in Quebec city region. In big American cities, authorities consider that one young person out of 100 engages in this profession. Statistics for other regions are not available because police interventions is not very active in this area.
8. In Montreal, the red light district used to be downtown. But increasingly prostitutes are working in different areas of the city, in places where they were not seen five years ago. They do not always work in groups like before. Brothels in Montreal are illegal and that law seems to be respected.
9. In Quebec, people without jobs may receive a minimal living allowance through the welfare system, a Provincial government service.
10. One Canadian dollar is appropriately the equivalent of RS 25.